Rosie Butler, LLB student at the University of Sheffield, on how the police can respond to the evolving challenges of ‘revenge porn’ and ‘deepfakes’.
In 2024, the NPCC identified technology-enabled violence as a key threat to women and girls, and as part of the reason why violence against women and girls (VAWG) is now being tackled by the police on par with terrorism and organised crime.[1] This blog post focuses on a particular kind of technology-facilitated VAWG, non-consensual intimate image abuse (NCIIA), commonly referred to as ‘revenge pornography’, which involves the non-consensual sharing, or threat of sharing, of an intimate image of a person, including synthetic sexual content (also known as ‘deepfakes’). This blog will:
- Set out the key challenges facing police in responding to NCIIA;
- Consider how to keep police responses one step ahead of this evolving type of crime.
To do this, I draw on critical analysis of relevant legislative frameworks, such as the Online Safety Act 2023, and police policies, including the VAWG Strategic Threat and Risk Assessment from the Vulnerability Knowledge & Practice Programme (VKPP) and the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC) VAWG Delivery Framework, as well as a review of relevant literature.
This was undertaken as part of my LLB research project at the University of Sheffield, supervised by Professor Layla Skinns.
The Challenges
This analysis showed that the legislative framework surrounding NCIIA is becoming increasingly comprehensive, at least on paper, through the Online Safety Act 2023 and the upcoming Crime and Policing Bill, [2] allowing more victims of abuse to come forward for successful prosecutions. The Online Safety Act 2023 resolved gaps highlighted within the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 by broadening image definitions to include intimate images that hadn’t previously been covered by legislation, such as images of a person in their underwear or transparent clothing, in addition to synthetic sexual content. This piece of legislation also created the offence to threaten to share intimate images, further protecting potential victims, since this threat is often more powerful than the actual act of disclosure, as it gives power to the abuser to coerce victims.[3] However, whilst legislation is improving, police responses appeared to be lagging behind.
The police policies I reviewed showed surprisingly little mention of NCIIA. Where policies did focus on online VAWG, stalking and harassment were highlighted as the key issue, despite the VKPP identifying NCIIA as likely to become the predominant type of offence committed against women in online spaces in the future.[4] My research identified three key challenges for the police response to NCIIA.
Advancements of Technology: too analogue and not yet digital enough?
Whilst national bodies, such as the VKPP and NPCC, showed awareness of rising levels of NCIIA, this was less so for frontline officers. In 2018, Bond and Tyrrell found a tendency for police to misunderstand the technicalities of various online platforms, and only 1.2 percent of officers felt that they had excellent understanding of NCIIA,[5] impacting their confidence in investigations and effectiveness in responding to victims. This may be because of greater emphasis still on the analogue, with officers being trained to police traditional and offline crimes which result in physical injury to victims.[6] Additionally, many forces are still relying on outdated systems for policing NCIIA, yet 21st century policing depends on the effective use of data and technology,[7] including that which can spot cases involving synthetic sexual content for effective investigations.
Inconsistency of police responses across England and Wales
With limited discussion of NCIIA in relevant national policies and limited national mechanisms for identifying threats arising from emerging technology,[8] there is a risk of creating inconsistent approaches across England and Wales for both victims and police officers when it comes to responding to NCIIA on the frontline. Established in 2026, the National Centre for Violence Against Women and Girls and Public Protection (NCVPP), an initiative between the College of Policing and NPCC, aims to develop an effective whole force response by supporting chief constables to prioritise VAWG across all teams and departments, not just specialist units.[9] Nevertheless, the national toolkit on VAWG contains no definitive standards of the police response to online VAWG,[10] or any specific response to NCIIA. Hence, the charity End Violence Against Women proposed that VAWG policy should be addressing all forms of VAWG in a more consistent but also integrated way.[11]
Under-reporting by victims
VAWG and online offences are both significantly under-reported to the police, consequently when the two intersect, an even greater reporting gap is created.[12] This under-reporting to the police may come about due to the inconsistent responses, or general poor experiences, other VAWG victims face when reporting.[13] This is likely to be compounded by the police’s uncertainty and unfamiliarity about what NCIIA is and the legislative framework surrounding it, leading to ineffective management of cases.[14]
A Call for Empirical Research
The second aim of this blog is to consider what this all means for the police, if they are to stay one step ahead of this type of crime in the future. Firstly, this involves multi-agency working with collaborations between legislators, the police, researchers and other organisations to allow for the flow of information and evidence to guide policy making. Previous examples of research-led, evidence-based police policy, such as Operation Soteria, has highlighted its effectiveness in bridging the gap between researchers and the police to reorganise the way in which they worked.[15] This therefore calls for more research to be undertaken in this field to guide future policies.
Future research is necessary to investigate the true extent of police understanding of NCIIA. Current policy responses suggest that the police are not as fully engaged with NCIIA, as might be expected given its potentially significant impact on women and girls now and in the future. Operationally, there appears to be an unhelpful combination of them not having enough resources or expertise available, resulting in a lack of momentum to prioritise NCIIA. However, it may be speculative to suggest that the police are helplessly falling behind, and further research is needed to robustly examine this. Additionally, horizon scanning must take place to identify risks before they cause serious harm. This approach has already somewhat taken place, as the VAWG Risk Assessment clearly highlighted that NCIIA is likely to become the predominant form of online VAWG.[16]
Staying One Step Ahead
As technology continues to rapidly evolve and generate new methods to abuse, it is ever more important for the police to keep up. Horizon scanning must continue across the police to ensure that they stay one step ahead of criminals. As well as bringing consistency across police forces, the NCVPP aims to reduce the prevalence of VAWG by working with partners and specialists to identify and share effective approaches.[17] This initiative must also expand to NCIIA, with a multi-agency response between the police and researchers to allow for the sharing of current and advancing research evidence to guide effective police policies.
About the Author
Rosie Butler recently completed her LLB at the University of Sheffield. She is now beginning her career within the criminal justice system as a Prisoner Custody Officer, working within the courts and gaining valuable practical experience.
If you want to find out more about the research covered in this blog, please contact Professor Layla Skinns at L.Skinns@sheffield.ac.uk.
[1] Vulnerability Knowledge & Practice Programme, ‘VAWG Strategic Threat and Risk Assessment’ (VKPP News, 13 December 2024) https://www.vkpp.org.uk/news/2024-vawg-statement/ accessed 21 June 2026
[2] Sophie Mortimer, Andy Phippen and Emma Bond, Ten Years of the Revenge Porn Helpline: Understanding the Evolution of Intimate Image Abuse: Policy, Practice and Victim Support (Palgrave Macmillan 2025) 88
[3] Andy Phippen and Emma Bond, ‘Why do legislators keep failing victims in online harms?’ (2024) 38(2) International Review of Law, Computers & Technology 195, 202
[4] Vulnerability Knowledge & Practice Programme, ‘VAWG Strategic Threat and Risk Assessment’ (VKPP News, 13 December 2024) https://www.vkpp.org.uk/news/2024-vawg-statement/ accessed 21 June 2026
[5] Emma Bond and Katie Tyrrell ‘Understanding Revenge Pornography: A National Survey of Police Officers and Staff in England and Wales’ (2018) 36(5) Journal of Interpersonal Violence 1, 12
[6] Antoinette Raffaela Huber, ‘Image-based sexual abuse: Legislative and policing responses’ (2025) 25(3) Criminology & Criminal Justice 736, 745
[7] His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services, ‘State of Policing: The Annual Assessment of Policing in England and Wales 2024-25’ (HMICFRS, 10 September 2025) https://hmicfrs.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/publications/state-of-policing-the-annual-assessment-of-policing-in-england-and-wales-2024-25/ accessed 21 June 2026
[8] Giles Herdale, Keely Duddin and Olga Jurasz, ‘Landscape Review: Policing Technology-Facilitated and Online Violence Against Women and Girls’ [2025] Centre for Protecting Women Online https://oro.open.ac.uk/104074/ accessed 19 April 2026
[9] College of Policing, ‘Our priorities and focus areas: National centre for violence against women and girls and public protection’ (College of Policing, 12 March 2026) https://www.college.police.uk/national-centre-violence-against-women-and-girls-and-public-protection/our-priorities accessed 21 June 2026
[10] Giles Herdale, Keely Duddin and Olga Jurasz, ‘Landscape Review: Policing Technology-Facilitated and Online Violence Against Women and Girls’ [2025] Centre for Protecting Women Online https://oro.open.ac.uk/104074/ accessed 19 April 2026
[11] End Violence Against Women, ‘60+ orgs set out expectations for the VAWG strategy’ (EVAW, 8 September 2025) https://www.endviolenceagainstwomen.org.uk/60-orgs-set-out-expectations-for-the-vawg-strategy/ accessed 21 June 2026
[12] Ibid.
[13] Olga Jurasz, ‘Online Violence Against Women: A Four Nations Study’ [2024] The Open University https://oro.open.ac.uk/96398 accessed 21 June 2026
[14] Emma Bond and Katie Tyrrell ‘Understanding Revenge Pornography: A National Survey of Police Officers and Staff in England and Wales’ (2018) 36(5) Journal of Interpersonal Violence 1, 14
[15] Elizabeth A. Stanko and Sarah Crew, ‘From Project Bluestone to Operation Soteria Bluestone: An Academic-Police Collaboration’ (2022) 2 International Criminology 229, 300
[16] Vulnerability Knowledge & Practice Programme, ‘VAWG Strategic Threat and Risk Assessment’ (VKPP News, 13 December 2024) https://www.vkpp.org.uk/news/2024-vawg-statement/ accessed 21 June 2026
[17] College of Policing, ‘National centre for violence against women and girls and public protection’ (College of Policing, March 2026) https://https://www.college.police.uk/national-centre-violence-against-women-and-girls-and-public-protection accessed 21 June 2026